Which Car Insurance is Best?
Doug Stockman • April 29, 2025
The answer may not be quite clear.

tl;dr:
There's no single "best" car insurance company because everyone's needs are different, like ice cream flavors. Instead of getting overwhelmed comparing yourself or dealing with endless calls from filling out online forms, Select Source Insurance, an independent agency right here in the Upstate, does the shopping for you. They consider your specific situation to find the best coverage and price from various trusted companies. Think of them as your insurance matchmakers. Call 864-585-8318 to find your perfect fit!
Now, if you were expecting a definitive answer, a shiny gold medal draped across the metaphorical shoulders of one single insurer, well, grab a lukewarm cup of coffee and settle in. The truth, my friends, is about as straightforward as trying to parallel park on a busy Saturday.
The "Best" is a Moving Target.
You see, declaring one car insurance company the absolute "best" is like saying there's one single "best" ice cream flavor. Have you ever tried to choose a flavor at Baskin and Robbins? Sure, vanilla's a classic, but what about the die-hard chocolate chunk aficionados or my favorite, Pralines and Cream? Or the adventurous pistachio lovers? Everyone's got their own taste, and the same goes for insurance needs.
What's perfect for your neighbor with a squeaky-clean driving record, a sensible sedan, and a garage that's actually used for parking might be a total mismatch for you, the proud owner of a jacked up truck who occasionally navigates unpaved backroads (and might have a lead foot – no judgment).
So, if there's no single "best," what's a responsible driver to do?
That's where the magic of an independent insurance agency comes in, and yes, that's us! We're not tied to any single insurance carrier. We're like your Instacart for personal insurance shopping, sifting through a variety of options to find the perfect fit for your unique situation.
Think of it this way: those big-name insurance companies you see plastered all over TV? They're like department stores. They have a lot of options, but the salespeople are only pushing their own brand. We, on the other hand, are like your local boutique – we handpick from a curated selection of different, competitive and national insurers, focusing on finding the one that truly complements your style (read: driving habits and insurance needs).
What We Consider (and What You Should Too):
When we're on the hunt for the "best" insurance for you, here are some of the factors we weigh:
Coverage Options:
Does the policy offer the protection you need? We're talking beyond the basics of liability and uninsured protection. What about collision, comprehensive, underinsured motorist, roadside assistance or even car rental reimbursement? Do they have those extra bells and whistles you might want, like accident forgiveness, new car replacement, trip interruption or customization coverage?
Price (of course!):
While the cheapest isn't always the best, we understand that budget matters. We'll compare quotes from multiple reputable, well known, financially sound companies to find competitive rates without sacrificing essential coverage.
Discounts:
Who doesn't love saving money? We'll explore all the potential discounts you might qualify for, from good driver discounts to multi-car or home and auto bundles.
Financial Stability:
You want an insurance company that will be there when you need them. We look at their financial ratings to ensure they're stable and reliable.
Customer Service and Claims Handling:
This is where the rubber meets the road (pun intended!). How easy is it to get in touch with them? What's their reputation for handling claims efficiently and fairly? We pay attention to these details because we know how stressful a claim can be.
Our "Best" Advice? Talk to Us!
We are constantly on the search for the most competitive companies, sound and customer service driven companies.
Instead of endlessly scrolling through comparison websites and getting lost in a sea of jargon, or filling out some online form that sells your info to 30 different agents, why not let us do the heavy lifting? If you fill out one of those unknown insurance marketing website forms, watch out! They can sell your information to insurance companies all over the country. Some insured's have had to change their phone number because of so many calls because the calls don't stop.
We are right here in the South Carolina Upstate serving many communities, like, Spartanburg, Boiling Springs, Inman, Duncan, Lyman, Roebuck, Moore Woodruff, Pauline, Cowpens, Chesnee and many more. We know the best coverage because we live here and know exactly what you need.
We'll take the time to understand your individual needs, your driving habits, your vehicle, any youthful drivers and your budget. Your information stays private with us. We do not sell your information. You have one point of contact but get rated by many national competing companies. Then, we'll present you with tailored options from a variety of trusted insurance companies. Once you become our customer (look at our 5 Star Google Reviews) if you ever become unhappy with the company, we place you with (all companies eventually raise rates), we can place you with another competitive company that is available with the best rates in the current market.
Think of us as your insurance matchmakers. We're here to connect you with the policy that offers the best coverage, the right price, and the peace of mind you deserve.
So, is there one single "best" car insurance company? Probably not. But is there a best car insurance company for you? Absolutely. And we're here to help you find it. Give us a call today – let's ditch the guesswork and get you properly protected. 864-585-8318

The TL;DR (No Cap) Car insurance isn't some cheugy boomer paperwork. It’s about protecting your present and future bag. It’s what turns a life-altering financial disaster into a manageable Tuesday. Think of your insurance agent as your hype squad. We're here to explain the tea on deductibles, coverage limits, and make sure you're not paying for a policy that’s mid. The Bottom Line: Don’t simp for a cheaper premium that leaves you exposed. Get the right coverage. Secure your whip. Protect your peace. That's true main character energy. The Tea on Car Insurance: Why Do I Need to Drop Stacks on Something I(hopefully) Won't Even Use? Hey besties. Let's be real. Nobody is stoked about spending their hard-earned cash on car insurance. It feels like one of those things your parents—bless their hearts, they're kind of cheugy—keep telling you is "essential." You’re probably thinking, "Big Yikes, is this even a vibe? Why do I need to drop stacks on something I (hopefully) won't even use?" We get it. You're trying to save your bag, maybe finally afford that drip, or just keep that avocado toast habit alive. But hear us out, because don't simp for cheaper premium, because life without car insurance is seriously not the vibe, and honestly? That’s some major delulu behavior. 🚗 Scenario 1 : You're on Vibe Check Street and Things Go Sideways Picture this: You’re cruising, the playlist is absolutely slapping, and you're feeling like the main character. Then, BAM! A chaotic squirrel runs into the road, you swerve, and now your bumper is looking kinda… mid (or worse, completely busted). Without car insurance, that little "oopsie" instantly becomes a gigantic L. You are now personally funding the body shop, which is an express ticket to Brooksville (population: you). If you have a loan, your lender is going to be shook—and not in a good way. The Insurance Slay: If you have comprehensive and collision coverage, you can low-key just file a claim. You pay your deductible (which is usually much smaller than a whole repair bill), and your insurance company steps in and says, "Bet." Suddenly, that Big Yikes situation is just a minor inconvenience, not a financial dumpster fire. You're winning, which is a big fat W. 💥 Scenario 2 : It Wasn’t You, It Was Karen Okay, so let’s say you are driving perfectly. You have that rizz behind the wheel. But then, some absolute NPC runs a stop sign and totals your whip. What about your car? If the other person has terrible insurance (or, yikes, none), and you only have basic liability, your car is toast, or is it? Would you be getting ghosted by your savings account? The Insurance Slay: If you went for Uninsured(required)/Underinsured Motorist Coverage (which is a total flex), your policy steps up to pay for your stuff (up to the limits) when the other driver is broke or capping about their coverage. You get your ride fixed, you avoid being salty, and you keep the good vibes rolling. What if it is your fault? This is where your Liability Coverage is the real MVP. Legally, you need this at a bare minimum. It means if you are at fault for an accident, your insurance pays for the other person's damages (car repairs, medical bills, etc., up to the policy limits) so that they don't drag you in court and take your house money. Do you have the right limits? Ready to stop being delulu and get a quote that actually slaps? Hit us up. We'll make it quick, easy, and not at all cheugy. Bet! Our clients live in Spartanburg, Boiling Springs, Inman, Duncan, Roebuck, Moore, Lyman and the general upstate.

Ugh, My Rate Went Up for a Not-at-Fault Accident? It's the ultimate insurance head-scratcher. You're driving along, minding your own business, and then BAM! Some other driver turns your day into a metal-crumpled mess. But wait, it's not your fault! The police report says so, the other driver's insurance company agrees, and you're feeling pretty good about the whole thing. You and the other driver are not hurt and now your car is fixed. Then you get your renewal notice. Your heart sinks. Your insurance rate has gone up. But…why? Didn't we just establish that you were the innocent bystander in this whole debacle? It's a frustrating, perplexing situation that feels about as fair as getting a parking ticket for a car you don't even own. At Select Source Insurance, we hear this question a lot. We get it, it's maddening. So let's try to demystify this insurance riddle together, one slightly-less-maddening explanation at a time. The Crystal Ball of Risk Insurance companies are essentially professional fortune-tellers. They use all sorts of data to predict who is most likely to file a claim in the future. The "riskier" you appear, the more you're likely to pay for insurance. A not-at-fault accident, while not your fault in the traditional sense, can still be a blip on their risk radar. Here's what they're seeing: You're on the road more. If you're involved in an accident, even if it's not your fault, it indicates you're spending time on the road where these things happen. The more you drive, the higher the chance of being in an accident, even if you are the world's most defensive driver. Driving Habits: Even if you're not at fault, an accident can be a sign of unsafe driving habits. Consider this common scenario: you're following a car too closely, and they suddenly hit their brakes. You manage to stop in time, but the car behind you doesn't, resulting in a rear-end collision. While you may not be considered at fault, your decision to tailgate created a domino effect, leading to the crash. This is just one of many examples of how a lack of attention to safe driving practices can contribute to an accident. Stand Alone: This one incident, in and of by itself, may not impact the rate that much, but if another incident similar or different it will have more impact on the rate. The insurance company starts to see a pattern. The "Luck" Factor. Some insurance companies use a more statistical approach. They see that you've been in an accident, and their data might show that people who have been involved in one accident, even a not-at-fault one, are slightly more likely to be involved in another. It's not a judgment on your driving skills, but a cold, hard, and somewhat comical statistical reality. The Cost of Doing Business. Even in a not-at-fault claim, your insurance company might still have to pay for things. They might cover the rental car while your vehicle is being repaired or towing until they're reimbursed by the other driver's insurance. These costs, however small, are still part of a claim, and claims affect rates. The Solution: We Can Help! So, what's an innocent driver to do? The good news is, you're not stuck. This is precisely where being an independent insurance agency like Select Source Insurance makes all the difference. We aren't tied to a single insurance company. We work with a whole bunch of them! If one company decides to punish you for being a victim of circumstance, we can shop around for you. We can find a different insurance company that has a more favorable view of not-at-fault accidents. Think of us as your personal insurance matchmaker. We know which companies are more forgiving and which ones are more likely to raise rates for even the smallest claim. Our job is to find you a policy that offers great coverage without making you pay for someone else's mistake. The Bottom Line Yes, it's a bit ridiculous that your rates can go up for a not-at-fault accident. It's one of those bizarre insurance quirks that makes you want to shake your fist at the sky. But it's not a dead end. Give us a call. We'll do the shopping and negotiating for you. Let us find you a rate that reflects your driving, not someone else's.

Getting your Spartanburg vehicle tax refund: A guide from Select Source Insurance. Did you sell, trade, or wreck (as in a total loss) your vehicle? Did your vehicle get repossessed, or have you moved out of state? You may be eligible for a refund! We understand that navigating property taxes can be confusing, especially when life events like selling or wrecking a car come into play. Many Spartanburg residents don't realize they might be eligible for a refund on their vehicle property taxes in such situations. At Select Source Insurance, we're here to help clarify the process and ensure you get the refund you deserve. When are you eligible for a refund? Spartanburg County offers vehicle property tax refunds in several instances: Selling, Trading, Wrecking, or Repossessing a Vehicle Returning a Leased Vehicle Moving Out of State before your vehicle tag decal expires Transferring a tag does to another vehicle does not qualify What documentation do you need? The required documentation varies depending on why you are seeking a refund. The Spartanburg County Auditor's Office may require: a Bill of Sale Trade-in agreement A statement from your insurance or repossession company Documentation from the leasing company Your new out-of-state registration. How to apply for your refund? You can apply: in person by email: countyauditor@spartanburgcounty.org. by mail: to the Spartanburg County Auditor's office at 366 N. Church Street, Suite 200, Spartanburg, SC 29303 We're here to help Understanding vehicle property tax refunds can be complex. As your local independent insurance agency, we are here to assist with your car insurance needs and related questions. Here is a link: Spartanburg County Tax Refunds Also, did you know you can turn a vehicle tag in online? Yes, it is called a virtual tag turn in or decommissioning a tag. Here is the link: Decommission a Tag If you have questions about eligibility or need help with documentation, contact Spartanburg County. Informational purposes only. Check with the appropriate government entity for actual process.
