Why Did My Car Insurance Rate Double When I Added My Teen Driver?

TL;DR: Lowering Your Teen Driver's Insurance

Adding a teen to your policy is a major milestone, but it doesn't have to break your budget. Here’s how to save:

• Policy Bundle: Add them to your existing plan rather than getting a separate one.

• Safety First: Opt for a reliable used car over a "sporty" or brand-new model.

• Earn Savings: Take advantage of discounts for good grades, telematics, distant student and driver's ed courses.

• Strategic Coverage: Consider higher deductibles and check for bundling discounts.

Need a quote? Contact Select Source Insurance at (864) 585-8318 to find the best rates in Spartanburg.

 

Let’s be honest—nothing ages a parent faster than handing over the keys to a freshly licensed teen driver. One moment you're teaching them how to parallel park without taking out a mailbox, and the next… your insurance bill arrives looking like it’s been secretly training for a heavyweight fight.

We get it. At Select Source Insurance, we talk to parents across Spartanburg, Boiling Springs and the Inman areas every week who love their teens dearly—but don’t love the sudden spike in auto insurance premiums. The good news? There are ways to keep costs manageable while still giving your teen the freedom (and responsibility) that comes with being behind the wheel.

Here are some parent-approved, budget-friendly ways to help keep those premiums in check:

 

1. Add Them to Your Existing Policy

It’s almost always cheaper to add your teen driver to your policy rather than having them get their own. Plus, your multi-vehicle and multi-policy discounts still apply. Think of it like putting them on the family cell phone plan—only fewer text messages and more learning experiences.

2. Choose the Right Car (Translation: Not the Shiny One)

Teens don’t need a brand-new sedan with heated seats and a turbo engine. A safe, modest, reliable used car often comes with much lower premiums. Look for vehicles with solid safety ratings, reasonable repair costs, and absolutely nothing described as “sporty.”

3. Encourage Good Grades

Most carriers reward good students with a discount—sometimes a substantial one. So if your teen claims that homework is “optional,” this is your moment to remind them that A’s and B’s now come with real-dollar perks.

4. Sign Them Up for a Safe Driving Course

Approved defensive driving courses can reduce risk and insurance costs. Plus, it gives your teen a chance to hear safe-driving advice from someone other than you (a win for everyone involved).

5. Raise Deductibles (If It Makes Sense)

If your family can comfortably afford a higher deductible, it can help lower monthly premiums. Just be sure the budget can handle it if a claim becomes necessary. You know… “hypothetically.”

6. Review Your Coverage

Adding a teen driver is the perfect time to sit down with an independent agency (like us!) and review your policy. We’ll make sure you’re properly covered without paying a penny more than you need to. Sometimes even small adjustments can make a noticeable difference in your premium. We have many insurance companies to choose from offering you the best coverage for the best rates.

7. Ask About Every Possible Discount

From telematics programs to multi-policy bundling, carriers offer more discounts than most parents realize. We’ll help you explore them all—because saving even a little helps when you now have a driver who believes gas should magically refill itself.

---

Adding a teen driver doesn’t have to blow your budget. With the right guidance, good choices, and a little humor, you can navigate this chapter with confidence. And if you ever need a hand comparing quotes or finding savings, our team at Select Source Insurance Group is right here in Spartanburg to help.

After all, we’ve helped hundreds of families through this stage—and we promise, you’ll survive it too.

Need help reviewing your auto insurance or exploring discounts?
We’d be happy to take a look. Give us a call at (864) 585-8318 or visit our website to get started.